Quinn versus Gilligan: Specialist Hack against Mainstream?

| Comments | No TrackBacks
David Quinn, a journalist based in Manchester, posted on his blog that last night's Dispatches by Andrew Gilligan was actually trading off a three year old story. And David should know, because he covers the Manchester property market, which was the subject of the story.

And somebody claiming to be Andrew Gilligan has responded:

The programme did not say or imply that the Manchester story had been "discovered" by Dispatches or was an exclusive. Please get your facts right before you attack other people's.

There's two interesting things here. Firstly, it's revealing that mainstream TV journalism thinks that covering three year old stories is OK. And secondly, it's very interesting that blogging is giving specialist journalists a more powerful voice when their mainstream colleagues bulldozer their way into their areas of expertise.
Share on Tumblr

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.onemanandhisblog.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/3068

Comments

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Adam Tinworth published on July 31, 2007 6:20 PM.

More Rules of Online Communities was the previous entry in this blog.

Blogging A Magazine Article Before Print Publications is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Subscribe to OM&HB

Subscribe via e-mail:

Social Networks

One Man's Activity

  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "@richardkendall @kevglobal I enjoyed it very much."
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "There needs to be a word for the vague sense of dissatisfaction you feel when you download a mag app - and it doesn't use Newsstand"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "Friday night. Victoria. February. 80% commuters wrapped for winter. 20% clubbers with incipient hypothermia."
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "@currybet whoops. Sorry - too much drinking, not enough looking at the phone…"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "Google index is scary fast sometimes. A photo from my last #Newsrw blog post is getting Googke Images traffic already."
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "I'm at Cask Pub And Kitchen (6 Charlwood St., at Tachbrook St., Pimlico) http://t.co/tsDsTAdi"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "And that's the #newsrw liveblogging concluded. Remember folks, I'm available for weddings, bar mitzvahs and a new job… ;-)"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "And that's the final #newsrw - Social Media Standards and Scuttlebutt - done http://t.co/IUYUY9xa (now with photos)"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "RT @lheron: Philosophy aside, how would an employer actually retain the SM followers of an ex-employee? Not quite practical. #newsrw"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "Social media standards at #newsrw http://t.co/IUYUY9xa (liveblogging)"

Archives