An Electoral Retreat From Twitter

| 2 Comments | 1 TrackBack
I am a perpetual floating voter. I have political opinions, but no strong party loyalty - and I've voted for all the main parties and some minority ones in the elections I've participated in over the last couple of decades. There's a simple reason for this: I believe that the cut and thrust of discussion is at the root of politics, and the more tribal you are in your politics, the more likely you are to say "Party X must never get into power again", the less likely you are to engage in discussion in a thoughtful, intelligent way.

And this is a rather long-winded way of explaining why I've largely abandoned Twitter during this election campaign. Whereas most of my reading pre-election came from links on Twitter, now most of my stream seems to be filled with tribal posturing and links to "amusing" photoshopping of election posters. It seems to me, well, petty. And not a little childish.

Have I retreated to newspapers? No. The depressing predictability of the tribal voices on our national press has lead to precious little that inspires, informs or educates in them. Instead, I've found myself actively seeking out more intelligent and cogent debate on blogs (including, admittedly, some from national newspaper journalists) and sites specifically dedicated to political discussion like Talk Issues. This is one of those times when the 140 character limit of Twitter works against it. While it's great for sloganeering and creating a comfortable little echo chamber of like political minds, it leaves not room for detail, for debate, for politics. Now some of these blogs are tribal. They are from people of a particular political stripe - but they tend to wear their allegiance openly, and are prepared to engage in genuine debate with people who hold different views to them. And that's the critical difference - genuine engagement in discourse. Frankly, I find it depressing watching social media advocates who normally shout about the conversation to the high heavens suddenly becoming slogan-spouting machines, just because there's an election on.

And so, for now, you'll find me scanning Twitter, but living in my RSS reader and amongst the blogs, where I can actually learn something.
Share on Tumblr

1 TrackBack

TrackBack URL: http://www.onemanandhisblog.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/5993

There has been a bit of a backlash this week on the use (or lack) of Social Media tools in the current UK election vs what was predicted, and a view that teh mainstream media still rules. I'm not sure, and I offer three thoughts: You see what you measu Read More

Comments

I read this as "I might just be voting for a different party to my Twitter peers so I wont be retweeting anything they post".

No?

MT Adam Tinworth

Well, given that I have Twitter peers who are clearly Labour, LibDem, Tory and Green supporters, I'm bound to be voting for a different party to a good proportion of them..

So, no. Your comprehension is in error. I genuinely have no idea whom I'm going to be voting for at this point. Back at university the student union election had a "new election" category - an effective "none of the above". If that was there, I'd vote it like a shot.

Leave a comment

What a user pic? Get a Gravatar!

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Adam Tinworth published on April 26, 2010 2:50 PM.

News Values vrs Personal Experience was the previous entry in this blog.

Office Priorities is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Subscribe to OM&HB

Subscribe via e-mail:

Social Networks

One Man's Activity

  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "@richardkendall @kevglobal I enjoyed it very much."
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "There needs to be a word for the vague sense of dissatisfaction you feel when you download a mag app - and it doesn't use Newsstand"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "Friday night. Victoria. February. 80% commuters wrapped for winter. 20% clubbers with incipient hypothermia."
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "@currybet whoops. Sorry - too much drinking, not enough looking at the phone…"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "Google index is scary fast sometimes. A photo from my last #Newsrw blog post is getting Googke Images traffic already."
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "I'm at Cask Pub And Kitchen (6 Charlwood St., at Tachbrook St., Pimlico) http://t.co/tsDsTAdi"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "And that's the #newsrw liveblogging concluded. Remember folks, I'm available for weddings, bar mitzvahs and a new job… ;-)"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "And that's the final #newsrw - Social Media Standards and Scuttlebutt - done http://t.co/IUYUY9xa (now with photos)"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "RT @lheron: Philosophy aside, how would an employer actually retain the SM followers of an ex-employee? Not quite practical. #newsrw"
  • Adam Tinworth tweeted, "Social media standards at #newsrw http://t.co/IUYUY9xa (liveblogging)"

Archives